A recent ruling by the Alabama Supreme Court has left a military family uncertain about their ability to have another child through in vitro fertilization (IVF). Julie Eshelman and her husband conceived their 2-year-old daughter through IVF and kept their frozen embryos in storage, hoping to keep the option available for growing their family. However, with the family being redeployed to Alabama, that option is now shrouded with uncertainty following the recent state Supreme Court ruling. The court declared that embryos are children, even if they are outside of a uterus, and that those who destroy them can be held liable for wrongful death. The ruling could make the already high costs of infertility treatments substantially higher and discourage Alabama providers from offering them at all. The couple now faces a difficult decision: undertake the risk of moving the embryos to Alabama or bear the cost of lifelong storage fees of embryos they will never be allowed to discard, even if they don’t want any more children.
The ruling has raised concerns among local LGBTQ+ organizations, who are calling for accountability against those promoting anti-transgender rhetoric, which some speculate might have contributed to the attack on Nex Benedict, a nonbinary student who passed away after a fight with other students at Owasso High School in Oklahoma. The tragedy comes amidst a broader context of rising anti-LGBTQ+ violence and increasing anti-transgender legislation across the United States.
The Alabama Supreme Court’s decision could potentially impact fertility treatments and the freezing of embryos, which had previously been considered property by the courts. The ruling is stating that a fertilized egg, which is a clump of cells, is now a person. It really puts into question the practice of IVF. The decision could discourage medical providers from performing infertility treatments in fear of being held liable each time an embryo does not turn into a successful pregnancy and force parents to pay for lifelong storage fees of embryos they will never be allowed to discard, even if they don’t want any more children. The ruling adds another layer of uncertainty to an already difficult and costly process for families like Eshelman’s.
The ruling could potentially increase the costs associated with IVF and force Alabama’s fertility clinics to close, making fertility treatments such as IVF inaccessible to people in Alabama. Physicians hope the Alabama legislature will limit the impacts of the ruling, but they warn that the most dire consequence of the ruling is that some Alabama IVF clinics may be forced to suspend their operations. Even if they remain operational, patients could have to endure longer and more costly treatments to try to achieve a pregnancy. The challenge to IVF in Alabama comes as the number of pregnancies conceived through the procedure has soared over the past years.
The ruling has sparked widespread shock, anger, and confusion over how to proceed after the state Supreme Court ruled that frozen embryos are people, a potentially far-reaching decision that could upend women’s reproductive healthcare in a state that already has one of the most restrictive abortion laws in the country. The ruling could have a significant impact on reproductive healthcare in Alabama, potentially upending IVF procedures and freezing of embryos, which had previously been considered property by the courts. Attorneys are warning that divorce settlements that call for frozen embryos to be destroyed may now be void. Throughout Alabama, there is widespread shock, anger, and confusion over how to proceed after the state Supreme Court ruling.
Darren Trumbler is a versatile content writer specializing in B2B technology, marketing strategies, and wellness. With a knack for breaking down complex topics into engaging, easy-to-understand narratives, Darren helps businesses communicate effectively with their audiences.
Over the years, Darren has crafted high-impact content for diverse industries, from tech startups to established enterprises, focusing on thought leadership articles, blog posts, and marketing collateral that drive results. Beyond his professional expertise, he is passionate about wellness and enjoys writing about strategies for achieving balance in work and life.
When he’s not creating compelling content, Darren can be found exploring the latest tech innovations, reading up on marketing trends, or advocating for a healthier lifestyle.